Sugar + Butter Baking Co.

We are no longer taking custom cookie orders

Sign in or Create an Account

Cart 0
Cart 0
  • Home
  • Shop
    • Custom Sugar Cookies
    • Baking Supply
  • About us
  • FAQs
  • Contact Us
  • Sign in
  • Create an Account
  • Home
  • Shop
    • Custom Sugar Cookies
    • Baking Supply
  • About us
  • FAQs
  • Contact Us
  • Sign in
  • Create an Account

Shop For

More categories ›
VEGAN PRODUCTS
VEGAN PRODUCTS
VALENTINES HEART COOKIE
VALENTINES HEART COOKIE
MINI HOLIDAY BAG PRE ORDERS
MINI HOLIDAY BAG PRE ORDERS

Custom sugar cookies-no longer taking custom orders

More custom sugar cookies ›
Request a Quote for Custom Cookies-NO LONGER TAKING CUSTOM ORDERS

Request a Quote for Custom Cookies-NO LONGER TAKING CUSTOM ORDERS

Regular price $000 $0.00

bakery supply

More baking supply ›
Sold Out
Apple Cookie Cutter

Apple Cookie Cutter

Regular price $300 $3.00
Sold Out
Electric Guitar Cookie Cutter

Electric Guitar Cookie Cutter

Regular price $300 $3.00
Sold Out
Cake with Stand Cookie Cutter

Cake with Stand Cookie Cutter

Regular price $300 $3.00
Sold Out
Hexagon Cookie Cutter

Hexagon Cookie Cutter

Regular price $300 $3.00

Made with Love

Sarah McKie is one of the Niagara Region's leading cookie artists. Each Sugar + Butter Baking Co. cookie and treat is handmade, meticulously designed and baked with love. We love celebrating life's special occasions with you.


Quick links

  • Terms of Service
  • Return Policy
  • Privacy Policy
  • Shipping Policy

You dream it up and we can bake it happen.

Located at 11 Summer St St.Catharines Ontario

Contact us for a custom quote.

Join our Pro Bakers Mailing List

Discount codes, promotions, and new products. Directly to your inbox.



  • © 2026 Sugar + Butter Baking Co.
  • Powered by Shopify
Payment icons
  • American Express
  • Apple Pay
  • Diners Club
  • Discover
  • Google Pay
  • Mastercard
  • PayPal
  • Shop Pay
  • Visa
  • choosing a selection results in a full page refresh