Collections – Sugar + Butter Baking Co.

We are no longer taking custom cookie orders

Sign in or Create an Account

Home
Shop
- Custom Sugar Cookies
- Baking Supply
About us
FAQs
Contact Us
Sign in
Create an Account

Home
Shop
- Custom Sugar Cookies
- Baking Supply
About us
FAQs
Contact Us
Sign in
Create an Account

Home › Collections

Custom Sugar Cookies

Custom Sugar Cookies

MINI HOLIDAY BAG PRE ORDERS

MINI HOLIDAY BAG PRE ORDERS

Angel Fish Cookie Cutter

VALENTINES HEART BROWNIE

VALENTINES HEART BROWNIE

VALENTINES HEART COOKIE

VALENTINES HEART COOKIE

Quick links

Terms of Service
Return Policy
Privacy Policy
Shipping Policy

You dream it up and we can bake it happen.

Located at 11 Summer St St.Catharines Ontario

Contact us for a custom quote.

Join our Pro Bakers Mailing List

Discount codes, promotions, and new products. Directly to your inbox.

Email

© 2025 Sugar + Butter Baking Co.
Powered by Shopify

Payment icons

choosing a selection results in a full page refresh