Valentines Day Custom Cookies - Request a Quote

PLEASE NOTE: ORDER DEADLINE IS FEBRUARY 10, 2022. ALL ORDERS WILL BE AVAILABLE FOR PICKUP ON FEBRUARY 12, 2022. SUGAR + BUTTER BAKING CO. WILL BE CLOSED ON FEBRUARY 13 AND 14.

Handmade, custom-designed sugar cookies in Vanilla or Chocolate flavours. If you can dream it, we can bake it! Here's a sampling of our best Valentines Day designs. Browse our other designs for ideas of how to personalize your order for your loved one!

Cookies are $36.00 per dozen and for individual wrapping with ribbon, please add $3 per dozen

Custom orders must be placed 7 days in advance.

At Sugar + Butter Baking Co., we believe you should never have to pay for your dietary restrictions, so gluten free and vegan options are available at no additional charge.

Please note: This is a quote request. We will be in touch within 1 business day to confirm if your date is available and to discuss design options. Please continue to checkout and complete the checkout process. You will not be asked for your credit card information. Payment will be required upon booking your custom order.